Open Letter to President Joe Biden: A Call for Clemency for Dr. Aafia Siddiqui

Excellency President Biden

Greetings

I extend my heartfelt congratulations to you and your family on the recent presidential pardon granted to your son, Hunter Biden and over 1500 Americans. This act of compassion exemplifies the healing power of second chances and reflects the values of grace, justice, and humanity that the United States stands for. 

In this spirit, I humbly urge you to consider granting clemency to Dr. Aafia Siddiqui, who has endured a staggering 86-year prison sentence under highly controversial circumstances. Her prolonged suffering and the inhumane conditions of her incarceration stand in stark contrast to the principles of human rights, dignity, and fairness that are central to the American identity. Extending mercy to her would not only rectify a long-standing injustice but also reaffirm America’s commitment to justice and compassion on the global stage. 

The Historical Bonds Between Pakistan and the United States 

The United States and Pakistan share a deep and enduring relationship that has spanned decades, rooted in mutual cooperation and shared sacrifices. Since its independence, Pakistan has stood alongside the United States, offering unwavering support in critical moments of history: 

– Pakistan played an instrumental role (at its own peril)  in supporting the U.S. objectives during the Cold War, particularly through alliances like SEATO and CENTO, and during the Afghan-Soviet conflict, after which only due to the single-handed Pakistani efforts America became the sole super power on this planet.

– Pakistani forces helped save countless American lives in Mogadishu and during other international crises. 

– When the U.S. Embassy in Islamabad came under attack, Pakistan’s courageous intervention ensured the safety of American personnel. 

– Pakistan has also shown grace and understanding in complex situations, such as facilitating the release of Raymond Davis despite legal and moral challenges. 

– In the aftermath of the U.S. withdrawal from Afghanistan in 2021, Pakistan provided safe passage for thousands of Americans, ensuring their safety in a critical moment. 

These examples underscore Pakistan’s steadfast friendship and its readiness to assist the United States even in the most challenging circumstances. Clemency for Dr. Siddiqui would be seen as an acknowledgement of this partnership and would generate immense goodwill not only in Pakistan but across the Islamic world. 

The Enormous Sacrifices of the Pakistani Nation 

Over the past 35 years, the Pakistani people have borne unimaginable costs in their partnership with the United States, particularly in the global fight against terrorism. The toll of this prolonged conflict has been staggering: 
More than 100,000 Pakistani civilians and military personnel have lost their lives in the fight against terrorism, making it one of the most devastating conflicts in recent history. 

– Pakistan’s economy has suffered losses exceeding 2 trillion USD in direct damages and opportunity costs due to terrorism-related disruptions and instability. 

– Entire communities have been uprooted, livelihoods destroyed, and generations scarred by the violence and insecurity that this war has brought. 

Despite these sacrifices, Pakistan continues to fight this 35 years long, still unending war with resilience and determination, often at great cost to its own stability and development. This enduring commitment underscores the depth of Pakistan’s partnership with the United States and its dedication to shared global security objectives. 

The Humanitarian Case for Clemency 

Dr. Siddiqui has already served over two decades in prison, during which she has endured unimaginable suffering. Her ordeal has become a symbol of perceived injustices against Muslims worldwide, fueling narratives of grievance and mistrust. By granting her clemency, you would not only demonstrate the strength of American justice but also send a powerful message of reconciliation and hope. 

This act of mercy would not compromise U.S. security or legal principles; rather, it would showcase America’s ability to balance justice with compassion. It would also serve as a profound gesture of goodwill, fostering better relations with Pakistan and the broader Islamic world, while reaffirming America’s moral leadership. 

A Strategic Gesture for Long-Term National Interest 

In an increasingly interconnected world, where public perception and diplomatic goodwill hold significant weight, granting clemency to Dr. Siddiqui would serve the U.S. national interests in several ways: 

– It would enhance America’s image as a nation that values humanity and justice, resonating deeply with millions of people worldwide. 

– It would strengthen ties with Pakistan, a crucial partner in a geopolitically sensitive region, at a time when collaboration is needed more than ever. 

– It would mitigate anti-American sentiments and foster an environment of dialogue and mutual respect. 

Mr. President, your leadership has always been defined by empathy and a commitment to unity. By granting clemency to Dr. Aafia Siddiqui, you have the unique opportunity to heal wounds, strengthen alliances, and demonstrate the transformative power of mercy. 

I respectfully urge you to take this step, not just for the sake of one individual, but as a testament to the enduring values of compassion, justice, and humanity that define the United States of America. 

Sincerely, 

Syed Nayyar Uddin Ahmad
+92 321 9402157
Lahore – Pakistan